'Shelby Oaks' Rotten Tomatoes Verified Audience Score Thread

I will continue to update this post as the score changes.

Rotten Tomatoes Popcornmeter: Hot

Audience Says: N/A

Audience	Score	Number of Reviews	Average Rating
Verified Audience	67%	100+	3.7/5
All Audience	58%	100+	3.4/5

Verified Audience Score History:

77% (3.8/5) at 50+
72% (3.7/5) at 50+
67% (3.7/5) at 100+

Rotten Tomatoes: Fresh

Critics Consensus: Shelby Oaks may stumble in its final moments, but its atmospheric tension and emotional core firmly establish it as a chilling debut from director Chris Stuckmann.

Critics	Score	Number of Reviews	Average Rating (Unofficial)
All Critics	60%	84	6.10/10
Top Critics	25%	16	4.80/10

Metacritic: 41 (17 Reviews)

SYNOPSIS:

A woman’s obsessive search for her missing sister leads her into a terrifying mystery at the hands of an unknown evil.

CAST:

Camille Sullivan as Mia Brennan
Brendan Sexton III as Robert Brennan
Michael Beach as Detective Burke
Sarah Durn as Riley Brennan
Robin Bartlett as Norma
Keith David as Morton Jacobson

DIRECTED BY: Chris Stuckmann

SCREENPLAY BY: Chris Stuckmann

STORY BY: Chris Stuckmann, Samantha Elizabeth

PRODUCED BY: Aaron B. Koontz, Cameron Burns, Ashleigh Snead, Chris Stuckmann

EXECUTIVE PRODUCERS: Mehki Bradley, David Brown, Anthony Buckner, Joel Cyr, Giles Daoust, Thomas Deasey, Sean E. DeMott, Angel Djambazov, Bryan Wayne Dull, Catherine Dumonceaux, Jeremy Dunham, The Feeshes, Michael Filsaime, Mike Flanagan, Garfield, Mark Gogolewski, Adam F. Goldberg, Shant Hamassian, Paul Holbrook, Benjamin Peter Hughes, Christine Jacobs, Anthony Killough, Dino Kontos, Ky Lee, Chase Lehocky, Trevor Macy, Darren Marlar, Michael M. Murillo, Andy Minh Nguyen, Melinda Nishioka, Bob Portal, Tushar Rakheja, Ronald A. Reyes, Bryan Roley, Adam Schmidt, Arthur Sevalho, Inderpal Singh, Brent Starheim, Ravi Subasegaran, Xspectre8

DIRECTOR OF PHOTOGRAPHY: Andrew Scott Baird

PRODUCTION DESIGNER: Christopher Hare

EDITED BY: Patrick Lawrence, Brett W. Bachman

COSTUME DESIGNER: Shawna-Nova Foley

MUSIC BY: James Burkholder, The Newton Brothers

CASTING BY: David Guglielmo

RUNTIME: 99 Minutes

RELEASE DATE: October 24, 2025

by chanma50

View 3 Comments

3 Comments

No_Pipe1370 on October 25, 2025 12:50 pm

That metacritic score, yikes
Lincolnruin on October 25, 2025 12:51 pm

Oh dear.
N8DKL on October 25, 2025 12:56 pm

Whenever I see the name Chris Stuckmann I just think of this meme – [Every Chris Stuckmann Review Ever](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UObCyoU_nGc)

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Midsommar (2019) Pelle presents Dani with a portrait he drew of her, the same signature is later seen on the frock Dani is wearing to compete for May Queen.

Marvel’s ‘Punisher: One Last Kill’ Mocked for “Unfinished” VFX Shot, Audio Issues

Jennette McCurdy was honored by the National Eating Disorders Association at their annual gala for her powerful advocacy, courage, and commitment to changing the conversation around eating disorders and mental health

A Spanish carnival group dressed as Stephen Hawking for a performance aimed at raising awareness about ALS, the disease the late physicist lived with for decades. The troupe, called “A Chirigota in Theory,” performed at the Official Carnival Groups Competition.

‘Shelby Oaks’ Rotten Tomatoes Verified Audience Score Thread

3 Comments