Share.

    41 Comments

    1. MarvelsGrantMan136 on

      Jackson:

      >“I won’t talk about any particular examples of actors because it’s a personal, private thing and it’s not their fault. Anytime we recast an actor, it’s actually our fault because we didn’t get the casting right and we cast the wrong person for a role. It’s not because they did anything wrong. So, I’m not going to talk about individuals, but you just got to realize that what you were imagining isn’t really quite happening, which means that we got it wrong and so we take full responsibility.”

      >“Ryan is a fantastic actor, as we know. Films are a chemistry both on camera and behind the camera, They’re chemistry in terms of what the actor conveys to the audience of the film. It’s just a complicated sort of amalgam of communication of how somebody gels into a group of people, into a story, into a character. It’s complicated and usually you try very hard when you’re planning the film, casting it, trying to get that gel kind of right, but occasionally we make our own mistakes.”

    2. mithridateseupator on

      This does seem like an obvious one Ryan

      Before you gain 60 pounds for a job, double check you were supposed to do that.

    3. herewego199209 on

      I can’t watch movies involving the abuse of children or animals, but I watched a tiny bit of the lovely bones in high-school and while the movie did nothing for me the few minutes of Stanley Tucci’s performance was so disturbing.

    4. hardyflashier on

      I’m still in awe of the fact they somehow got the phrase ‘the lovely bones’ into the dialogue of the actual film

    5. LeelooDallas88 on

      Yeah, and then they replaced him with Mark Wahlberg, who stuck out like a sore thumb amongst the cast… He was so out of place in Lovely Bones.

    6. Regular-You2119 on

      Regardless of his weight I refuse to accept he would have been worse than Mark Wahlberg

    7. lokiandbutters on

      When the movie (and book) is called the lovely bones, the title calls it lovely bones and the first time it’s mentioned in the article they call it the lonely bones, i can no longer take the article seriously.

    8. I remember back in high school we watched Lovely Bones. You can imagine how a classroom full of young teenagers reacted to it.

      It was joked about for the remainder of high school in our friend group.

    9. BananaSoprano on

      I love that he put on all that weight and Peter Jackson just went, “Why did you do this?”

    10. duct_tape_jedi on

      Am I the only one who thought that the two pictures in the post were the before and after pics of Gosling’s weight gain?

    11. kvlt_ov_personality on

      This reminds me of the time I got hired at McDonald’s and the weekend before my first day I got a huge full sleeve tattoo of Grimace, Ronald McDonald, Mayor McCheese, the Hamburglar, and the McNugget Buddies.

    12. ArchdruidHalsin on

      What’s even crazier is that he turned around and did Crazy Stupid Love, in which he is absolutely *cut*.

    13. Glanced at the thumbnail and first thought the second pic was Ryan after the sixty pounds.

      Sorry Peter.

    14. nightwing12 on

      Anytime you replace anyone with Mark Wahlberg we already know it’s your fault

    15. awayshewent on

      So weird he was hired in the first place — he wasn’t old enough to be a teen girls father at the time and there’s an 11 year age difference between him and Rachel Weisz, who would have been playing his wife

    16. Ryan’s told this story before in interviews. Says he was melting ice cream and drinking it to gain all the weight because of how the character is described in the novel. It’s pretty funny the way he tells it.

    17. I had to double take on the picture in the article cause peter jackson looked like older & fatter version of ryan gosling..

    18. SharpPink_GlitterInk on

      Is this a safe space to say that King Kong 2005 is very well shot but is hard to revisit because its over abundance of… everything… like its a movie with no self restraint so way too many of the action scenes go on way to long and this is also the problem with the final LOTR movie but at least that didn’t have King Kong and Dinosaurs playing on the swings. Like my mom and my sister and my sisters friend and her mom and me all piling into the car after my friends birthday party to see King Kong is etched into my brain as a core memory but its like… really boring as an adult.

    19. CursedSnowman5000 on

      Yeah? We’ve known this for years.

      Ryan wanted to look the part, gained the weight, was fired and Jackson bullshitted about it throughout the entirety of the 2010’s.

    20. Reading the article, seems Gosling had a different idea from Jackson of how the character should look which stemmed from a lack of communication from Jackson which Jackson admits fault for. Unfortunate.

    21. Ok-Nothing-4737 on

      Wahlberg over Gosling. Respectfully, that is tragically hilarious af.

    22. feldoneq2wire on

      I mean the whole movie missed the point. Changing actor on the dad didn’t have that big an effect. 

    23. Like_a_fine_skylark on

      Huh. I always thought he was supposed to play Stanley Tucci’s character.

    24. Not seen the film since it came out, was it necessary for his character to be in shape? Feel like the marketing also didn’t make much of a deal outside of the daughter and nonce from what I remember so casting of a overweight person shouldn’t be a danger to box office numbers either.

    25. Gosling was way too young for the role. Then he gained 60 pounds, for whatever the hell reason. Peter definitely was to blame for even considering him.

    26. “Speaking to THR in 2010, Gosling said “we had a different idea of how the character should look. I really believed he should be 210 pounds. We didn’t talk very much during the preproduction process, which was the problem.”

      Ryan basically said it was his fault

    27. Ashen_Larry on

      If Mark Wahlberg was going to be let go, it wouldn’t have went down like it did. There would have been a lot of blood on set and then him saying “Ok we’re going to film somewhere safely, don’t worry.”

    28. NopeNahNoMore on

      lol, this remains my favorite “method” acting story of all time. They’re like: nah, get Marky Mark.

    Leave A Reply